WINSON 文森律师事务所

LEGAL INSIGHTS

Making economies more sustainable: what role for industrial hubs?

English

Developing countries can use spatial policies to reduce their ecological footprint while simultaneously increasing their competitiveness.

By Kasper Vrolijk and Tilman Altenburg

Aerial view of industrial buildings in Nova Bana, Slovakia. (Image: halfpoint via Envato)

Most countries face enormous environmental challenges, from global warming and overexploitation of water resources and fertile soil, to air pollution. Environmental degradation has become a global issue, with a majority of countries demonstrating their commitment to ambitious climate targets and climate change adaptation policies by joining the Paris Agreement and pledging to fulfil the Sustainable Development Goals.

Such policies may have large-scale economic repercussions, including a shift by industry to renewable energy sources, the implementation of innovative agricultural practices, and material reuse and recycling. Many of these changes are already being observed empirically: investments in renewable energy are exceeding investments in non-renewable infrastructure1, and plastic products are increasingly being banned or are heavily taxed2.

In this context, how can developing countries reduce their ecological footprint but at the same time also benefit from climate policies? In a recent article3, we examine to what extent spatial policies can be useful in addressing environmental challenges while also providing opportunities for structural transformation and competitiveness. Three types of agglomerations are identified: 1) green cities; 2) green clusters, and 3) eco-industrial parks.

Building green cities to reduce their environmental footprint

Firms and people tend to cluster in agglomerations for good reason: the localized supply of and demand for labour, goods and services; and the intensified circulation of knowledge and ideas. Moreover, cities are also characterized by higher transport efficiency, comparatively lower residential energy consumption and lower GHG emissions because of the density between individuals and between businesses.

Due to increasing urbanization and the fact that urban areas account for 75 per cent of GHG emissions4, cities must become more sustainable. Making them more sustainable also entails economic co-benefits, since the costs related to congestion and pollution decrease. For example, congestion, air pollution and climate change in Beijing were estimated to cost between 7.5 per cent and 15 per cent of the city’s GDP.5

Population and carbon footprint in urban areas

原始图表数据 · 500 行 × 4 列(点击完整展开)

保留来源全部数据和原始顺序,空白单元格不补造;这是来源历史数据,不是本年度沙特统计。

Original source chart data
CityPopulation (millions)Carbon footprint (Mt CO2)Label
Seoul21.254276.1Seoul
Guangzhou44.309272Guangzhou
New York13.648233.5New York
Hong Kong SAR6.029208.5Hong Kong
Los Angeles13.482196.4Los Angeles
Shanghai23.804181Shanghai
Singapore5.235161.1Singapore
Chicago7.26152.9Chicago
Tokyo/Yokohama32.999132.8Tokyo/Yokohama
Riyadh5.747118.8Riyadh
Dubai4.971110.8
Wuxi12.01110.4
Johannesburg11.049105.2
Tehran12.671104.4
Moscow14.45399.5Moscow
London9.48698.9London
Benha34.55687.2
Beijing19.91983.7Beijing
Jakarta36.35183.7Jakarta
Al-Ahmadi2.69780.6
Miami5.03180.3
Samut Prakan15.08380
Paris10.1278Paris
Dallas4.67476.9
Tianjin7.97171.4
Istanbul13.58770.9
Detroit2.7770.6
Philadelphia3.59170.2
San Jose4.00370
New Delhi27.2369.6New Delhi
Cologne6.94269.6
Houston4.52466.1
Jeddah3.28763.1
Washington D.C.3.28562.3
Osaka15.56658.9
Buenos Aires13.86957.5
Mexico City19.82155.7Mexico City
Shah Alam6.33653.9
Taipei8.59253.3
Phoenix3.27952.1
Wuhan7.28551.2
Hangzhou7.01949.2
Toronto5.05549.1
Nanjing6.32344.7
Shenyang5.57344.6
Melbourne3.18544.4
Shantou11.04843.8
Madrid4.94943.4
Kolkata24.79242.9Kolkata
Pusan3.06442.3
Sydney3.53341.2
Xi'an5.65341.2
Chengdu9.30840.5
Huhot1.79639.6
Boston1.9537.1
Baotou1.99136.8
Taiyuan3.51735.6
Denver1.82435.4
Athens3.27635.3
Atlanta1.8634.8
Seattle1.97334.1
Yinchuan1.33833.8
Sao Paulo19.7733.6Sao Paulo
Berlin3.21733.5
Manchester3.51233.2
Minneapolis1.51833
Zhengzhou4.55632.7
Chongqing4.97932.6
Doha1.12832.4
Mumbai21.4532.1
Ad Damman1.61132
Wenzhou4.94131.7
Quanzhou3.74831.5
Brisbane1.64431.4
Dalian3.28930.9
Tel Aviv-Yafo2.65330.6
Milan3.82530.4
Abu Dhabi0.91129.9
Saint Petersburg4.24429.6
Ankara4.26929.3
Qingdao3.57229.2
Nagoya7.73828.8
Montreal2.79528.3
St. Louis1.17728.3
San Diego1.94228.1
Jinan3.29528
Santiago6.22627.3
Rotterdam2.45427.1
Cape Town3.47226.8
Hyderabad8.39626.5
Ho Chi Minh City11.56226.3
Barcelona3.64826.1
Baltimore1.25425.4
Changchun3.32625.2
Almaty1.81425.2
Birmingham2.37425.1
Hefei3.87924.9
Shijiazhuang3.35824.9
Harbin4.13524.1
Cleveland0.97324
Fremantle1.27624
Durban2.83323.7
Las Vegas1.90423.5
Lima9.04323.2
Mashhad3.04422.8
Kansas City1.00422.7
Guiyang2.61922.3
Chennai9.48321.8
Caracas6.01121.6
Bangalore10.59121.6
Orlando1.43621.1
Baghdad5.2321.1
Sacramento1.48421.1
Bogota8.45520.5
Taegu1.91820.4
Urumqi3.03520.3
Vienna1.8120.2
Manila20.50720
Columbus1.00319.9
Esfahan2.15119.8
Sitrah2.04419.4
Portland1.16319.4
Indianapolis0.93819.4
Zibo1.68719.3
San Antonio1.26219.2
Taejon1.55119.2
Kota Yogyakarta6.96119
Chifeng0.67719
Hamburg1.719
Pune6.69718.9
Al Ain0.73818.5
Kwangju1.40818.5
Surabaja8.3718.4
Mecca1.18117.9
Vancouver1.71517.5
Datong, Shanxi1.51717.5
Xiamen3.26817.3
West Yorkshire1.5317.2
Ningbo2.57317.1
T'aichung2.95717
Kunming3.09816.9
Milwaukee0.82116.8
Tangshan1.76216.8
Rio de Janeiro9.20816.7
St. Petersburg0.79816.7
Monterrey4.08416.6
Changsha3.37116.3
Hanoi7.05616.1
Rome2.40816.1
Ningbo1.88215.7
Taizhou2.17515.6
New Orleans0.59615.6
Al Hofuf1.09115.5
Chios2.55515.4
Ulsan0.92215.4
Naples3.37215.3
Linyi, Shandong1.5115.1
Guadalajara4.46515.1
Kaoshsiung2.33415.1
Novosibirsk1.22915
Dhaka21.76415
Bandung8.02514.9
Calgary0.99714.9
Fuzhou2.52414.7
Pittsburgh0.60214.5
Austin0.95514.4
Amman3.58614.3
Tongliao0.56114.3
Salt Lake City0.91814.3
Medina0.94714.1
Adelaide0.84314.1
Gor'kiy1.15813.7
Luoyang1.82913.7
Warsaw1.78313.4
Changzhou1.28513.2
Chelyabinsk1.01913.2
Omsk0.95113.1
Astana0.83212.9
Maebashi/Takasaki1.37912.9
Norfolk0.69612.8
Fushun1.2312.8
Anshan1.57512.5
Louisville0.57512.3
Tabriz1.53912.3
Ahmadabad6.63512.2
Sohag6.17312.1
Edmonton0.79612.1
Kazan'0.95311.9
Munich1.63911.8
Cincinnati0.52111.8
Sverdlovsk0.9811.8
Lanzhou2.32111.7
Ahvaz1.27111.6
Semarang5.28111.5
Johor Baharu1.5311.5
B'abda2.14111.4
Copenhagen1.12511.4
Xuzhou1.7111.4
Rostov-on-Don1.01311.3
Buffalo0.5711.3
Prague1.12911.1
Oklahoma City0.5311.1
San Cristobal3.74411
Amsterdam1.04311
Bucharest1.78911
Weifang1.09910.9
Hartford0.56810.8
Maracaibo1.80610.8
Lahore10.88710.6
Budapest1.84710.6
Ashgabat0.88910.5
Tampa0.68910.5
Bridgeport-Stamford0.61210.5
Nanchang3.20610.4
Medan4.05610.4
Torshavn0.89310.4
Changwon0.69710.4
Frankfurt1.03510.4
Chonju0.62310.4
Brussels1.35610.2
Krasnoyarsk0.79810.2
Jinzhou0.84410.2
Katowice1.49910.1
Lakewood Township0.53310.1
Kuybyskev0.93510.1
Providence0.53410.1
Voronezh0.79410
Ch'ungju0.6749.9
Jilin1.5159.8
Kyiv2.669.8
Shiraz1.2219.8
Omaha0.4849.6
Valencia1.3879.5
Malapuram4.8129.5
Quito2.2529.5
Cheonan0.5819.5
Ondorhaan1.3329.4
Jaipur3.8199.4
Nanning2.3349.4
Jacksonville0.5529.4
Stuttgart1.0629.4
Alexandria4.4229.3
Baoding1.2389.2
1.1449.2
Putian1.1549.2
Curitiba2.6079.2
Dublin1.0059.2
Yeuqing1.1239.1
Stockholm1.1189.1
Liuzhou1.4799.1
Xiuying1.4949
Belo Horizonte3.9729
Dongsheng0.4489
Winnipeg0.6059
Karachi12.5619
Tucson0.5198.8
Chandigarh2.2478.8
Ufa0.8098.8
Tulsa0.3868.7
Baku1.8858.7
0.8628.7
Fuxin0.6748.7
Khabarovsk0.4958.7
Dongyang1.228.6
Krasnodar0.6988.6
Jiaozuo1.1368.6
Sarasota0.4348.6
Handan1.1958.5
Lucknow4.598.5
Baerum0.7138.5
Medellin3.2228.4
Cordoba1.3678.4
Nagpur2.9828.3
Carslbad0.5388.3
Anyang1.1618.3
Lisbon1.5638.3
Sheffield0.7048
Linfen0.6118
Ottawa0.6067.9
Zhuhai1.3287.9
Newcastle upon Tyne0.9557.9
Liaoyang0.6287.9
Nantong1.0457.9
Puebla1.9777.8
Antalya0.8887.8
Gold Coast0.3427.8
Oakland0.3987.7
Qinhuangdao0.8837.7
Fresno0.5757.6
Changzhi0.597.6
Indore2.8447.5
Turin1.2097.5
Volgograd0.5837.5
0.6127.4
Porto Alegre2.5017.4
Saratov0.6817.3
Albuquerque0.4317.3
Shymkent0.7487.3
Huaibei1.0447.3
Wuhu, Anhui1.067.2
Qom1.0387.2
Valencia1.2167.2
Coimbatore2.2137.2
0.8377.2
Tashkent3.5027.1
Huangshi0.7797.1
Grand Rapids0.3157.1
Zurich0.6477.1
Litong0.277.1
Pingdingshan, Henan0.8467.1
Yichang0.8377.1
Benxi0.7627
Ust' Ordynskiy0.5277
Changshu0.9187
Goiania1.8357
Casablanca3.8747
Yancheng, Jiangsu0.777
Bursa1.3657
Huashan0.7197
Hinggan0.2426.9
Vadodara1.9876.9
Shihar0.5926.9
Toluca1.3346.9
Algiers4.1296.9
Tijuana1.5426.9
0.6336.9
Iqaluit0.4346.8
0.7316.8
Polygyros0.6686.8
Asyut3.4796.7
Ulanqab0.2756.7
El Paso0.4636.7
Ciudad Juárez1.2896.7
Lyon1.1976.7
Port Elizabeth0.836.7
Porto0.9726.7
0.8696.6
Lalinzhou0.7526.6
Xinxiang0.8716.6
Tunis2.2146.6
Taian, Shandong0.7476.6
Kanpur3.7766.5
Huainan0.926.5
Jiaxing0.9856.5
Furth0.6576.4
Bristol0.5536.4
Hilo0.46.4
Havana1.7856.3
0.5686.3
Helsinki0.8586.3
Campinas1.6416.3
Astrakhan0.4986.2
Mohammed Bin Zayed City0.1886.2
Yaroslavl0.4986.2
Zunyi0.7566.2
Asansol3.2456.1
T'ainan1.0516.1
Guilin1.0246.1
Colorado Springs0.3446.1
0.5796.1
Dayton0.2786.1
Kaifeng0.7286.1
Tsentral'nyy Rayon0.4296
0.4796
Ludhiana2.0816
Jining, Shandong0.7796
Hengyang0.9396
Allentown0.3596
Hulun Buir0.1986
0.4755.9
Nanyang, Henan0.8575.9
Qiqihar0.8895.9
Auckland0.8575.9
Toledo0.2575.9
Zaozhuang0.5385.9
0.5025.9
Yuci0.4525.8
Rosario1.0125.8
Belgrade1.065.8
Tolyatti0.4425.8
Kermanshah0.7835.7
0.55.7
Izevsk0.5665.7
Jinxi, Liaoning0.5065.7
Kayseri0.8755.7
Lagos11.0145.7
Wichita0.2675.7
Tula0.4295.7
Richmond0.285.7
Raipur2.6845.7
Mudanjiang0.7195.6
0.5115.6
Recife3.0965.6
Lipetsk0.385.6
Bengbu0.8845.6
Malang2.6735.6
Ryazan0.4415.6
Barranquilla1.7775.6
Xining1.1795.6
Bilbao0.7235.6
0.9285.6
Barnaul0.4955.5
Nashville0.3155.5
Bhopal2.2775.5
Tyumen0.5085.5
Memphis0.2665.5
London0.3295.5
Kharkiv1.3915.5
Yuhu0.8665.5
Zhuzhou0.8495.5
Langfang0.5075.5
0.6975.5
Utrecht0.4715.4
0.765.4
Bayan Nur0.2935.4
Guayaquil2.3085.4
0.6015.4
Cali2.2195.4
0.5665.4
Dandong0.7285.4
Aktyubinsk0.4095.3
Nottingham0.6035.3
Rochester0.3065.3
Antwerpen0.7055.3
Donets'k1.0155.3
Hamilton0.4045.3
Luanda6.4535.3
Peshawar7.0155.2
Penza0.4165.2
Al Basrah1.4665.2
0.5275.2
Ypacarai2.4285.2
0.4625.2
Springfield, MA0.2915.1
0.4265.1
Kavaratti3.1065.1
Charlotte0.3535.1
Colombo4.3635.1
Jiamusi0.655.1
Zhenjiang, Jiangsu0.7645.1
Raleigh0.3435
Zhangjiakou0.6175
San Jose1.7895
Maracay0.7725
Fortaleza2.8365
0.65
Chilgok0.3045
Seville0.9095
Rasht0.5735
Tabuk0.4055
Hsinchu City0.6734.9
Sofia0.9424.9
Hannover0.6084.9
Aintab1.1984.9
Bakersfield0.4464.9
Florence0.7684.9
Stavropol0.4114.9
Kashi0.4534.9
Kaliningrad0.3674.9
Kemerovo0.3914.9
Tripoli1.24.9
Al-Jahrah0.1784.8
Newport News0.2514.8
0.414.8
Dnipropetrovs'k0.8264.8
Panama1.14.8
Kudymkar0.5684.8
Belgorod0.3154.8
Lille0.8374.8
Yinzhuzhen0.3084.7
Akron0.2094.7
Saint George's0.3894.7
0.5154.7
Barquisimeto0.8034.7
Vladivostok0.4624.7
Tomsk0.4174.7
Orenburg0.424.7
0.4534.6
Novokuznetsk0.384.6
Qianxixiang0.6254.6
Palm Springs0.2994.6
Torreón0.9924.6
Buraydah0.3044.6
0.4014.6
Varanasi4.1654.6
Unayzha0.2844.6
Surat3.6984.6
0.4344.5
Merida0.9034.5
Varamin0.5324.5
Cochin2.0134.5
0.7194.5
Mary0.6164.5
Arbil1.0914.5
Brasilia1.6844.5
Kursk0.3274.4
Daqing0.3794.4
Mendoza0.8554.4
Waterloo0.2824.4
0.3164.4

Source: Voiland (2019); Data from Moran et al. (2018).

One particularly important benefit of greening cities is the improvement in living conditions. In Kigali, a one-off investment of US$10 for an improved cook stove was estimated to reduce 90 per cent of air pollution, 1.6 tonnes of CO2 and US$181 in fuel costs over a four-year period.6

There are plenty of opportunities to make cities in developing countries more sustainable and efficient. In Mumbai, for example, solar cells could meet between 20 per cent and 31 per cent of daily electricity demand7, while in China, ground-source heat pumps could reduce energy consumption in public buildings by 25 per cent to 30 per cent8. Rolling out such green innovations in cities implies lower costs per household than in rural areas.

Cities in developing countries have a unique opportunity to incorporate ‘green’ principles; much of the urban infrastructure in developing countries is only just being built. Many parts of Asia and Africa have not yet fully urbanized – e.g. only 40 per cent of sub-Saharan Africa’s population resides in urban areas compared to 80 per cent in Latin America.9 It is much easier and less expensive to design a new sustainable city than trying to retrofit an existing one.

Although green cities provide many benefits, they are not automatically successful. Existing evidence points to a trade-off: large, ambitious green city projects such as Saudi Arabia’s “The Line” project, Masdar City in the United Arab Emirates and Dangton in China may have a huge impact in terms of reducing the environmental footprint, but the cities’ top-down design has given rise to problems related to societal acceptance and technical implementation; on the other hand, incremental improvements to existing cities, exemplified by Vauban Freiberg (Germany) and Hammarby Sjöstad (Sweden), are easier to implement with the support of local citizens, but are less likely to achieve radical decarbonization and resource savings. The challenge thus is to combine ambitious city reengineering with citizen involvement and societal acceptance.

Creating linkages in green clusters

Green industries have often emerged in locations characterized by high demand and widespread availability of resources and/or capabilities. In Germany, for example, which is one of the frontrunners in environmental agglomerations, several renewable energy clusters have emerged characterized by different dynamics: the City of Freiburg evolved as a hotspot of innovative solar start-ups in the 1970s, which subsequently led to the foundation of a world renowned research centre, the Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems (ISE). Solar Valley Mitteldeutschland became a manufacturing hub based on government subsidies to prompt greenfield investments. Finally, along the North Sea Coast, a wind technology cluster emerged, producing heavy equipment and offering a variety of technologies and services to the offshore wind parks located nearby. The success of all these clusters hinged on localized collaboration efforts between highly specialized firms.

Industrial park in Bellevue, Washington, US (Image: Mint_Images via Envato)

Cluster policies have been pursued in developing countries with similar zeal. In Morocco, the government envisioned the creation of solar clusters to turn the country’s highly favourable solar irradiation potential into a source of industrial development. In support of this policy, the government established the Moroccan Agency for Solar Energy (MASEN) in 2010, among others, to devise integrated solar projects, carry out technical studies and promote the inflow of foreign investment. This project has so far, however, not fully materialized due to lack of technological capabilities. Moreover, the level of complementary specialization and inter-firm cooperation remains low. Investments in large-scale renewable energy are dominated by foreign investors, while local firm involvement has largely been limited to public works and maintenance.10 This may change in the future, however, as a growing number of renewable energy projects are developed, and local engineering capabilities and demand for green hydrogen industries associated with renewable energy investments increase. Morocco has successfully established industry clusters in automotive and aeronautics; the challenge now is to apply the accumulated experiences to renewable energy industries.

Eco-industrial parks as a means to foster sustainable industries

Another option is for governments to develop industrial parks to foster cooperation and competition, and to enhance firm innovation and productivity. Governments often attract firms to parks that have ready-made infrastructure, with localized regulations and incentives or with ancillary services, such as power supply and housing. Eco-parks, which differ from normal industrial parks, provide additional services to firms to reduce their ecological footprint while simultaneously curbing their production costs.

There are different types of eco-industrial parks: one fairly standard service offered by such industrial parks are common facilities to treat effluents, to reduce waste and share renewable energy. In Ethiopia, the Hawassa Industrial Park, e.g. was built by the China Civil Engineering Corporation (CCECC) in 2016, bringing together 18 foreign and five domestic firms, to construct a zero-liquid-discharge common effluent treatment plant.11 Much more ambitious industrial parks can be designed by establishing a closed loop industrial system whereby outputs from one line of production are used as inputs in other industrial processes (“industrial symbiosis”12). China has been particularly successful in developing such eco-parks, proving that the environmental footprint can be reduced even though productivity is increased.13 For example, one of its heavy-metal industrial parks achieved a water reuse rate of 97 per cent through industrial symbiosis.14 A study involving 34 Chinese eco-parks found that their ecological performance increased through industrial symbiosis by nearly 90 per cent between 2007 and 2010, while their industrial value added grew by more than 60 per cent.15

Spatial policies can reconcile sustainability with competitiveness

Developing countries have a unique opportunity to use spatial policies to reduce their ecological footprint while at the same time increasing their competitiveness. Specifically, there are distinct cost advantages in incorporating green incentives and technologies in new cities, clusters and parks rather than retrofitting them ex-post.

We identify three advantageous spatial approaches: green cities, green clusters and eco-industrial parks. The most rewarding spatial approach is the focus on green cities, and changing incentives and introducing environmental technologies across diverse segments synchronously (e.g. in energy, housing and transportation). Such an approach can render numerous complementary benefits across economic, ecological and social dimensions.

- Kasper Vrolijk is Researcher at the German Development Institute.

- Tilman Altenburg is Head of the Department of Transformation of Economic and Social Systems at the German Development Institute.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the authors based on their experience and on prior research and do not necessarily reflect the views of UNIDO (read more).

References

1. IRENA. (2019) Renewable Energy Statistics 2019. Abu Dhabi: International Renewable Energy Agency.

2. Behuria, Pritish. (2019) The comparative political economy of plastic bag bans in East Africa: why implementation has varied in Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda. Global Development Institute Working Paper Series 2019-037. Manchester: University of Manchester.

3. Altenburg, Tilman and Vrolijk, Kasper. (2020) Greening Structural Transformation: What Role for Industrial Hubs? In: The Oxford Handbook of Industrial Hubs and Economic Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

4. Seto, Karen C. et al. (2014) Human settlements, infrastructure and spatial planning. In: Climate Change 2014: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge, UK and New York: Cambridge University Press.

5. Creutzig, Felix and He, Dongquan. (2009) Climate change mitigation and co-benefits of feasible transport demand policies in Beijing. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 14(2), 120-131.

6. Gouldson, Andy; Colenbrander, Sarah; McAnulla, Fayer; Kerr, Niall; Sakai, Paola; Hall, Stephen; Papargyropoulou, Effie and Kuylenstierna, Johan. (2015) Exploring the economic case for climate action in cities. Global Environmental Change 35, 93-105.

7. Singh, Rhythm and Banerjee, Rangan. (2015) Estimation of rooftop solar photovoltaic potential of a city. Solar Energy 115, 589-602

8. Kammen, Daniel M., and Sunter, Deborah A. (2016) City-integrated renewable energy for urban sustainability. Science 352(6288), 922-928.

9. World Bank. (2019) World Bank Development Indicators.

10. Vidican, Georgeta; Böhning, Matthias; Burger, Gina; de Siqueira Regueira, Elisa; Müller, Sandra and Wendt, Susanne. (2013) Achieving inclusive competitiveness in the emerging solar energy sector in Morocco. German Development Institute Study 79. Bonn: German Development Institute.

11. Mihretu, Mamo and Llobet, Gabriela. (2017) Looking Beyond the Horizon: A Case Study of PVH’s Commitment in Ethiopia’s Hawassa Industrial Park. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.

12. Balke, Verena; Evans, Steve; Rabbiosi, Liazzat; Averous Monnery, Sandra. (2017) Promoting Circular Economies. In: Altenburg, Tilman and Assmann, Claudia. Green Industrial Policy. Concept, Policies, Country Experiences. Geneva, Bonn: UN Environment; German Development Institute.

13. Zeng, Douglas Zhihua; Cheng, Lei; Shi, Lei and Luetkenhorst, Wilfried. (2020) China’s green transformation through eco-industrial parks. World Development 140, 105249.

14. Shi, Lei. (2015) Eco-Industrial Parks in China. Tsinghua University. Presented at the Eco-Industrial Park 2015 Conference. Cited from Kechichian, Etienne and Jeong, Mi Hoon. (2016) Mainstreaming Eco-Industrial Parks. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.

15. Liu, Wei; Tian, Jinping, Chen, Lujun; Lu, Wanying and Gao, Yang. (2015) Environmental performance analysis of eco‐industrial parks in China: A data envelopment analysis approach. Journal of Industrial Ecology 19(6), 1070-1081.

文末说明

来源:UNIDO Industrial Analytics Platform — Kasper Vrolijk and Tilman Altenburg ↗ · 发布日期:2021-02-18 · 收录日期:2026-09-09

作者:Kasper Vrolijk and Tilman Altenburg

Kasper Vrolijk and Tilman Altenburg, “Making economies more sustainable: what role for industrial hubs?”, UNIDO Industrial Analytics Platform, 18 February 2021. Original source: https://iap.unido.org/articles/making-economies-more-sustainable-what-role-industrial-hubs. Licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/. Narrative wording is unchanged; HTML formatting is normalized, the complete chart data are presented as a text table, and third-party photographs are omitted. Source chart credits: Voiland (2019), using Moran et al. (2018). No endorsement by UNIDO or the authors is implied.

使用条件与收录说明

复用依据 / 使用条款 ↗ · 许可条款 / License ↗

Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The publisher page explicitly states “IAP by UNIDO licensed CC BY-SA 4.0” and links to https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/. Attribute Kasper Vrolijk and Tilman Altenburg, the title, UNIDO IAP, original URL, date, and license. Retain attribution and license; license adaptations under CC BY-SA 4.0; add no restrictive terms or implied endorsement. The source chart cites Voiland (2019) and Moran et al. (2018); the underlying Moran article explicitly permits reuse under CC BY 3.0 at https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aac72a. Chart values are transcribed without alteration into a safe text table. The two Envato-credited photographs and all logos are excluded; their textual captions remain, without image files or image embeds. Original narrative wording is unchanged; only HTML formatting is normalized. Link destinations and rights checks are recorded in docs/source-evidence-public-originals.md.

本机演示访问限制不改变该许可授予的权利;仍须遵守其署名、改编及其他适用条件。

完整性与版本

共 14 个正文部分、39 个段落或表格块。英文或阿文与收录记录保持一致。

Complete text/data edition, not a facsimile of the website: standfirst, byline, all 15 narrative paragraphs, four narrative subheadings, chart heading and source note, all 500 original chart records and four columns, both photograph captions, both author biographies, publisher disclaimer, and all 15 numbered references are retained in source order. The chart is a newline-delimited pipe-separated text table, not an image. Original superscript reference numbers remain as plain digits; reference link destinations are preserved in the companion evidence document. The source chart contains 30 records with an empty City, including a final record with empty City and Label; source blanks are deliberately not invented or repaired. Excludes only photographs/logos, chart graphics whose full data are retained, navigation, sharing, newsletter/feedback widgets, and related-article promotions. This is historical analysis published 2021-02-18, with older cited data, not 2026 news or current Saudi/GCC emissions statistics.

来源 SHA-256:a3280ed114cf9372fc2c28fb0a0158d0657c01d4a841b7c52bc705e4a5436685

本篇为固定版本的本地资料导入;不计入授权法规试点,不自动发布,不自动审核,不表示来源机构认可本站。新闻报道与行业分析不是法条,不能单独认定具体项目适用。原始日期不改写为今天;第三方图片、网站导航与独立附件不冒充新闻正文。

READ → DISCUSS

这条行业动态,与你的业务有什么关系?

把所读来源与企业投资、交易或经营问题一并保存,供后续人工核对。资讯不是已经核验的项目法律意见。

当前仅保存到本机收件台,不自动联系律师或建立委托。